Skip to main content

Empire Magazine (2008) Greatest Movies List - #79: The Thin Red Line

I once saw an interview in which Christopher Plummer said that what Terrence Malick needs is a writer. He was referring to his experience shooting The New World, which saw his role considerably reduced. The same happened to a much greater extent with Malick’s war movie The Thin Red Line (1998), which saw the screen time of many movie stars reduced to mere minutes amid a 170-minute running time. However you have to hand it to the guy: he knows how to make anything look beautiful, including the carnage of war.

Malick’s movie came out the same year as Saving Private Ryan, so I think that year I had my fill of ultra violent war films and was no too interested in seeing it. Sixteen years later I finally caught up to it on Netflix, but in hindsight the big screen might have been a better option since this is a very visual story. The plot is pretty loose, following one American soldier and sometimes some of his brothers in arms as they make their way through World War II in the Pacific theatre of war, but throughout the cinematography by John Toll keeps reminding viewers the action is set in a beautiful place and oftentimes on a beautiful day. Even when Woody Harrelson accidentally blows off his rear end with a grenade you notice the lush vegetation around the soldiers and the blue sky above.

Supposedly the movie was to focus on Adrien Brody’s Cpl. Geoffrey Fife, but instead after months of editing the final cut puts the emphasis on Jim Caviezel’s Private Witt, who is first seen living with the natives in the South Pacific after having abandoned the army. To call him the protagonist would still be generous since after he is found and imprisoned the story then focuses on the invasion of a key Japanese location in Guadalcanal and Witt only rejoins the action later during the battle.

There is an interesting conflict between Lt. Gordon Tall (Nick Nolte), who seems like the kind of army man that sees the American flag every night in his sleep, and Captain Staros (Elias Koteas), who is hesitant to attack a Japanese controlled hill. It is easy for Tall to bark orders about taking that hill no matter how many lives might be lost, but Staros is the one on the front line seeing his fellow soldiers get killed as they attempt to defeat the Japanese soldiers who are shooting at them from an elevated position inside bunkers. Understandably, Stavros feels this battle might need a new strategy.

That main battle is about all you get in terms of plot. Throughout the rest of The Thin Red Line you get brief glimpses of a wide cast that includes John Cusack, Sean Penn, John C. Reilly, Jared Leto, Thomas Jane, Tim Blake Nelsom John Travolta, and even George Clooney for a brief moment. Even Mickey Rourke had some scenes, but they ended up being cut out of a first five-hour first cut. You get some brief scenes about life at home for some of these characters, but also many random scenes of the landscape, vegetation, and natives. The result is quite poetic amid the very graphic violence depicted on screen, but one wonders what the main plot is supposed to be.

I recently saw a stand-up special by Patton Oswalt in which he talks about how there are many male directors who will shoot hours and hours of footage and declare it a masterpiece. Then a woman calmly walks into the editing room to try to sort out the mess into a coherent movie. That might be a generalization, but it seems to have been the case with The Thin Red Line since editor Leslie Jones spent seven months editing the massive amount of footage. Eventually Billy Weber and Malick himself also participated in the editing process, resulting in the theatrical cut and the diminished screen time of many actors.

The end result is a movie that has a vague plot about the effect war has on soldiers and also about the beauty in the world when people are not busy trying to shoot each other. Every shot that does end up on screen is gorgeous, but you do wish there was a more straightforward narrative in order to remain engaged during the pauses in combat. 



Popular posts from this blog

Empire Magazine (2008) Greatest Movies List - #85: Blue Velvet

Exactly how do you describe a David Lynch movie? He is one of the few directors whose style is so distinctive that his last name has become an adjective. According to Urban Dictionary, the definition of Lynchian is: “having the same balance between the macabre and the mundane found in the works of filmmaker David Lynch.” To see a prime example of that adjective film lovers need look no further than Lynch’s Blue Velvet (1986), which does indeed begin in the mundane before slowly sinking in macabre violence.
My first introduction to the world of David Lynch was through his ground breaking, but unfortunately interrupted, early 1990s TV series Twin Peaks. This was one of the first television shows to grab viewers with a series-long mystery: who killed Laura Palmer? A mix of soap opera, police procedural, and the supernatural, it is a unique show that showed the darkness hidden in suburbia and remains influential to this day. Featuring Kyle MacLachlan as an FBI investigator with a love for …

Empire Magazine (2008) Greatest Movies List - #90: When Harry Met Sally...

There is an age-old question regarding whether single men and women can be just friends. In real life the answer is obviously “yes,” but in movies and TV the answer always has to be that at some point two single characters will get attracted to each other and move beyond friendship. On TV I find this to be contrived and overused, but some movies can have a lot of fun with the concept, most notably Rob Reiner’s comedy classic When Harry Met Sally…(1989). It may not change your view on love and friendship, but it forever changed the meaning of the phrase “I’ll have what she’s having.”
On paper this film’s premise sounds like another rom-com, but seen by oneself during an evening of Netflix binging it does make you think about deep stuff like the long-term impact of your decisions on your life. A person you meet during a tense trip might turn up again sometime later down the road in the most unexpected ways. If there is one thing I believe in it is infinite possibilities, and Nora Ephron…

Empire Magazine (2008) Greatest Movies List - #83: Brazil

Dystopian movies from the 1980s are a funny thing since we now live in the future of those movies and if you look at the news for more than five minutes it will feel as though we are one bad day away from being into a dystopia. On the plus side, if it ends up looking like the dystopia portrayed in Terry Gilliam’s Brazil (1985) at least we will have lovely architecture to look at while the government is busy telling us how to think. This might not be a movie that will cheer you up, but the production design is amazing, the performances are great throughout, and you get to see Robert DeNiro play a maintenance man/freedom fighter.
I first saw Brazil as a Terry Gilliam double feature at the Universit√© de Sherbrooke’s movie club paired along with 12 Monkeys around ten years ago. Those two films are similar in that they both feature a rather dour future and, as with most Gilliam movies, incredibly intricate sets. However the dystopian future in Brazil is somewhat scarier than the disease-ra…