Skip to main content

Empire Magazine Greatest Movies List - #405: Dirty Dancing


“Dirty Dancing” (1987) has been described as “Star Wars” for women. That may be true in terms of popularity, but story-wise we are talking about apples and oranges here. Just like “Footloose” and the “Footloose” remake, “Dirty Dancing” has a paper-thin plot that serves as an excuse to see well-toned people hit the dance floor and make it look improvised whereas they have been practicing for weeks. Of course it didn’t hurt the film that the male lead was Patrick Swayze, who, while not the best actor of all time, was one of the best on-screen dancers of all time.

So why did I decide to watch this movie? Two reasons: first, it’s on Empire Magazine list of Greatest Movies of All Times and I like to cross things off a list, even though I am not sure why it’s on the list. Second, when I saw it a year ago it was available on iTunes for 99 cents and I was low on cash. I was finishing my second semester in Journalism-New Media at Sheridan College, living off a student loan, and trying to save every dollar I had for, you know, food. But I still need some entertainment during my off hours, so if a movie is available to rent for almost a dollar, I may as well watch “Star Wars” for women.

The plot, for what it’s worth, is as follows. In the summer of 1963 17-year-old New-Yorker Frances “Baby” Houseman (Jennifer Grey) goes on a vacation to an expensive resort in the Catskills Mountains. Her wealthy father Jake (Jerry Orbach of “Law and Order” fame) is the personal physician of Max Kellerman (Jack Weston) the owner of the resort, so that helps to get a good room.

Baby develops a relationship with Johnny Castle (Patrick Swayze), the resort’s dance instructor. By day he’s teaching the old couples how to dance, but after hours he and the rest of the hotel staff get together and really let loose. Baby is taken aback when she sees them dancing dirty. She gets a chance to learn a lot more of Johnny’s moves when his dance partner Penny Johnson (Cynthia Rhodes) reveals she is pregnant. Baby convinces Johnny to let her become his new partner and they begin to train in secret for his performances at a different resort.

Penny’s pregnancy eventual adds whatever conflict the story can get at this point. When her backstreet abortion goes wrong, Baby calls on her father for help. He assumes Johnny is the father, when in fact Robbie (Max Cantor); the womanizing waiter is the one responsible. Doctor Jake is therefore upset at his sweet little girl for hanging out with such a character and forbids her from seeing him again. Yeah, of course a hormonal teen lusting after a buffed up Patrick Swayze is going to listen to daddy and stay away. In case you can’t tell, I am being sarcastic.

There is also a subplot involving thieves at the resort who will end up framing Johnny for their crimes, but that is irrelevant. The inevitable ending is Johnny sweeping Baby off her feet for a big dancing finale after uttering the immortal words “Nobody puts baby in a corner.” That final dance is beautifully choreographed to the tune of “(I’ve Had) The Time of My Life,” during which both Swayze and Grey do a good job, but their story is too shallow.

The fact is there really aren’t that many reasons why these two shouldn’t be together. So Johnny dances professionally for a living. Why is daddy so upset? It’s not like the man is an unemployed bum who is into drugs and alcohol. It might also have been more of a conflict if Johnny had been African-American. The story is set in 1963, wouldn’t it have been more topical and dramatic for the daughter of a rich white doctor to date a black staff member? Otherwise, why bother setting the story in the 60s?

There is an unavoidable remake on the way, which for once might be a good idea. If they do not simply recycle the same story with different actors, there is an opportunity to improve the script. Of course it will be tough to follow in the footsteps of Patrick Swayze who owns this movie and the dance floor. In the meantime, there is always the version with Charlyne Yi and Channing Tatum. It’s only five minutes long, but it’s already an improvement to cast the diminutive Yi opposite the hulking Tatum.



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Empire Magazine Greatest Movies List - #333: Grease

Nostalgia is a powerful feeling. You have some good times in a period of your life, time goes by and you feel like going back to that time period. I am guessing someone in the late 70s felt nostalgic about late 1950s high school life in America, leading to the creation of “Grease,” one of John Travolta’s first hits. The life and time are very dated today, but every now and then you still hear the soundtrack on classic rock stations. Clearly the lyricists did their jobs right. This is not my favourite musical. It’s cutesy with catchy tunes, but my top two musicals are “The Blues Brothers” and “The Rocky Horror Picture Show.” If it involves car chases, Ray Charles, the Time Warp, Meat Loaf, and Carrie Fisher with a rocket launcher then count me in. I have less enthusiasm for Danny Zucko singing about his summer love for Sandy. But the movie was available for a dollar on iTunes during an evening when I had nothing to do in University, so I might as well kill two hours and ...

Empire Magazine (2008) Greatest Movies List - #20: Blade Runner

  Ridley Scott’s Blade Runner (1982) is one of those movies that gets more relevant with each passing decade. Set in a (now passed) future in which Los Angeles is overrun with people and pollution, the story focuses on artificial lifeforms clashing with their human creators. As the chase for these lifeforms progresses, writers Hampton Francher and David Peoples imply they may not be so different from the humans chasing them. If this sounds topical in 2024, imagine how relevant it will sound ten years from now. When writing these amateur reviews, I usually try to think back on the first time I watched the movie and what I felt at the time. This is tricky with Blade Runner considering there have been five versions of the film released since the 1980s. I believe the first version I did see on TV was the original theatrical version with the narration to guide the audience since executives thought that was needed. I eventually disagreed and purchased the Final Cut on Blu-Ray to see th...

Empire Magazine (2008) Greatest Movies List - #357: The long Goodbye

  Sometimes in a detective story the mystery is not half as fun as the detective stuck in the chaos of the story. Philip Marlow is one of those detectives. His name is synonymous with Hollywood noir and in The Long Goodbye (1973), he dives deep into a mystery involving a murder, then a suicide, then a missing person, and eventually a very violent gangster operating in sunny Los Angeles. One thing I love about this version is that this detective loves his cat enough to go buy him food at three o’clock in the morning. Now that is a dedicated pet lover. The late great director Robert Altman starts the action at a slow pace to introduce Marlowe (Eliott Gould) as he wakes up to his hungry cat. Here is a man who falls asleep in his clothes, always the same suit and tie, and is either constantly smoking or lighting a new cigarette. He is a friendly person, nice enough to pick up an item for his neighbours while going out to get cat food. It probably helps that said neighbours are five y...